Ditch the Guesswork: Unveiling the Ultimate Pasta and Wine Pairings

ditch the guesswork: unveiling the ultimate pasta and wine pairings the three drinkers

Wine and pasta might just be one of the earliest earthly delights - timeless, classic, and infinitely delectable. It’s not hard to envision why for almost as long as we’ve been conscious of our palates and had the ability to make wine, we’ve been using it to enhance, complement and complete our most delicious dishes. To the uninitiated, the question of “which wine should I pair with my dish?” might be a daunting one! As with all things wine, there are layers of complexity. Your personal favourite wine is a wonderful place to start, but there is such a wealth of fantastic food and wine in the world and discovering them is so rewarding. 

Where do you begin?

Fortunately, we have teamed up with the phenomenal multi award-winning organic and biodynamic farm, Fattoria La Vialla, to find out the ultimate pasta and wine pairings.

What is Fattoria La Vialla?

What is Fattoria La Vialla? ditch the guesswork unveiling the ultimate pasta and wine pairings the three drinkers.jpg

Fattoria La Vialla not only make award winning wines but also specialise in making healthy food that tastes exactly as if it has just been freshly cooked by an Italian “nonna”. The beautiful, family-run, organic-biodynamic Farm and Wine Estate is situated near Arezzo in the Chianti region. It was already a farm over 200 years ago and was saved from ruin by the Lo Franco family in 1978. Since then, they have used biodynamic and organic farming practices to cultivate 1600 hectares of land and produce a wide range of delicacies including wine, cheese, pasta, olive oil and even cosmetics! They ensure the shortest possible journey and maximum freshness for their delicious offerings by cutting out the middleman and selling products directly from their website.

What exactly does it mean to be an organic, and biodynamic farm? Organic agriculture promotes the soils natural fertility without the use of chemical pesticides and fertiliser. It guarantees crop rotation, as well as periodic rest of the soil and the choice of selected varieties of plants. Organic also means GMO (genetically modified organism) free and ensures that farm animals have a great quality of life, free from the use of hormones, with ample space to graze which safeguards the dignity of the animals that thrive on the farm.

Biodynamic agriculture improves the biodiversity and fertility of the soil, the terroir. Consider, if you will, the idea that a farm is a single organism. The land, plants, animals and people live in a tight closed cycle. Fattoria La Vialla produce their own natural, biodynamic preparations and concentrated compounds to spray periodically on crops. The cultivation, production, recycling, and composting techniques used are those that were perfected long ago by their agricultural ancestors who proved it is possible to produce high quality products without the need for waste or chemicals. All of this work ensures the highest possible quality of goods for consumers.

Let’s talk Pasta

Let’s talk Pasta ditch the guesswork: unveiling the ultimate pasta and wine pairings the three drinkers Fusilli

We can’t talk about the perfect pasta and wine pairings unless we talk about the perfect pasta. For the dishes below, we used organic pasta from Fattoria La Vialla which is made from organic farm-grown durum wheat semolina and dried incredibly slowly at the lowest temperature possible (about 35-37°C) for between 44 and 48 hours. There are no added substances, and the simplicity of its creation preserves the nutritional properties of the pasta. Paying close attention to the water’s purity and properties, as well as the quality of the cereals to make the semolina, right through to the soil in which the wheat grows is vital to making delicious pasta – a practice that Fattoria La Vialla follow scrupulously. This attention to detail makes for restaurant quality pasta at home that is perfect for impressing your guests!

There might be some pasta styles that you’re yet to be acquainted with, so here’s a brief rundown of the pasta featured below.

Fusilli - This classic shape can be found everywhere in Italy. La Vialla’s Fusilli is deeply intricate with tight coils that bind to any sauce! Particularly excellent in veggie dishes. 

PiciA thicker spaghetti type pasta, deeply texturally satisfying and excellent with any rich red sauce. Patience is key here, with a twenty-minute cook-time that is oh-so worth it. 

Mini Farfalle - One of Fattoria La Vialla’s “mini pasta” shapes, that are every bit as firm and fresh as the full-sized pasta. Super doughy and perfect for pasta salads. The “mini” range all has the same cooking time, so you can even mix and match.

Tagliatelle - A staple at any good Italian restaurant, tagliatelle is wonderfully long, thick and accompanies almost any kind of sauce. It’s extra special with egg-based sauces. Be sure to stir delicately when cooking to avoid breaking! 

Spaghetti - By far the most popular pasta shape in and outside of Italy. Fattoria La Vialla’s Spaghetti is made in the traditional shape and size and is the ultimate Carbonara baseline. 

How Do You Pair Wine and Pasta? Top Tricks and Tips

How Do You Pair Wine and Pasta? Top Tricks and Tips ditch the guesswork: unveiling the ultimate pasta and wine pairings the three drinkers

Let’s keep this simple. Heavy sauce? Heavy wine. A super intense red sauce with red meat? Then a bold, tannic red wine, such as Sangiovese or even a Cabernet Sauvignon. Drop down in intensity, perhaps a lighter herbaceous tomato sauce? Try a Pinot Noir or a Merlot. Light, vegetable-heavy dishes pair beautifully with lighter wines that won’t dominate the intricate flavours of the dish, such as Sauvignon Blanc or a tantalising Riesling. 

For a truly perfect pairing, there might be more to consider. We’ve got you covered with five tips for the ultimate pasta and wine pairings.

  • Compare - Consider the ingredients and your dish and match it to the flavour profile of your chosen wine. Most wines list their tasting notes if you aren’t sure or are trying something new.

  • Contrast - Some of the best food combinations contrast rather than compare. Consider sweet against bitter, umami against sour. You can apply this logic to wine pairing.

  • Terroir: “If it grows together, it goes together” is the old food and drink industry saying. Put simply, local wine will pair beautifully with regional dishes. 

  • Acidity: As a general rule of thumb, a wine should be more acidic than your dish, but not so much it’s overpowering. Balance is key.

  • Trust yourself. Often, the best wine pairing is just your favourite wine with your favourite dish. Have fun! 

To kickstart your adventure into the delightful world of pasta and wine, we’ve selected seven perfect pairings for the next time you’re cooking to impress (or just for you, we won’t judge). 

The Best Pasta Dishes for Red Wine

Photo Credit - Fattoria La Vialla Best Pasta and Wine Pairings The Three Drinkers LeccioMoro Maremma Toscana Rosso D.O.C. 2022 Tagliatelle with Porcini Mushrooms and Pecorino.jpg

Eat: Tagliatelle with Porcini Mushrooms and Pecorino
Drink: LeccioMoro Maremma Toscana Rosso D.O.C. 2022

Ingredients (Serves Four)
350g Emmer tagliatelle 
300g porcini mushrooms
50g crustless stale bread
40g shelled hazelnuts
1 shallot
7 tbsp extra virgin olive oil
3-4 sage leaves
2 tbsp grated aged pecorino cheese
1 tbsp chopped parsley
salt and pepper (to taste)

Method: 
Clean the mushrooms and slice thinly, then set aside. Dice the shallot, sauté in a heavy bottom pan with 4 tbsp olive oil. Once translucent, toss in the mushrooms, add salt, pepper and torn sage leaves, then cook on medium for 10-15 minutes. Toast the chopped bread and hazelnuts with 1 tbsp olive oil. Boil the Tagliatelle until al dente and then strain - make sure to save some pasta water! Combine the pasta with the mushroom sauce and add a generous 2 tbsp of pecorino cheese, along with a spoonful or two of pasta water to help everything blend. Top with the toasted bread and hazelnuts and serve immediately with a drizzle of raw olive oil. Enjoy! 

The wine: This beautiful blend of 80% Sangiovese and 20% Merlot, Cabernet Sauvignon and Syrah bursts with berry fruits. The deep crimson colour hints at the wines’ age time - 12 months in oak, aiding the abundance of tannic properties you’ll find on the palate. Expect hints of spice and vanilla with a powerful berry punch.

The combination: This super umami, savoury, nutty pasta dish contrasts beautifully with the bold, jammy, fruity red wine. Absolutely perfect.

ABV: 14.5%
Size:
750ml
Find here:
£9.90

Photo Credit - Fattoria La Vialla Best Pasta and Wine Pairings The Three Drinkers Fusilli with Rosalina Sauce Casa Conforto Chianti Riserva D.O.C.G. 2019.jpg

Eat: Fusilli with Rosalina Sauce
Drink: Casa Conforto Chianti Riserva D.O.C.G. 2019

Ingredients (Serves 4) 
300g fusilli
500g bombolini cherry tomatoes
200g fresh ricotta
2 tbsp pecorino cheese
2 cloves of garlic
6 tbsp extra virgin olive oil 
fresh basil
salt, pepper/chilli pepper to taste

Method: 
Lightly fry diced garlic in oil, then add tomatoes and season generously with salt. Cover and cook at a medium heat for 10 minutes and then remove the lid and squash the tomatoes with a fork (this is the fun part). Cook another 2-3 minutes until thickened and then blend. Add torn basil leaves, the fresh (mash with a fork for the best texture) ricotta and pecorino cheese, then season with salt and chilli pepper. Once mixed, remove from the heat. Cook the pasta in salted boiling water, then strain and add, still hot, to the sauce. Garnish with fresh basil and tuck in! Top Tip: for an easier date night, Fattoria La Vialla actually batch up this delicious sauce - you can find it here!

The wine: 2019 was an odd year for Fattoria La Vialla. An extra rainy spring followed by an extra hot summer made for the ripest, juiciest grape yield for this decadent red blend of Sangiovese, Cabernet Sauvignon and Canaiolo. Aged for 24 months, this full-bodied wine boasts fantastic aromas of plum and blackberry. It’s bold, dry and endlessly sippable. 

The combination: If you love your dishes salty, cheesy and decadent, this one’s for you. Paired with Casa Conforto Chianti Riserva, the bold, dry red wine cuts through the rich cheese of the dish for a match made in heaven!

ABV: 14.5%
Size:
750ml
Find here:
£14.50

Photo Credit - Fattoria La Vialla Best Pasta and Wine Pairings The Three Drinkers Pici Pasta with Etruscan Sauce Sangiovese 100% I.G.T. 2022.jpg

Eat: Pici Pasta with Etruscan Sauce
Drink: Sangiovese 100% I.G.T. 2022

Ingredients (Serves 4-5)
400g Pici pasta
60g La Vialla style sun-dried cherry tomatoes
40g aged pecorino cheese
30g boiled eggs
30g black olives 
parsley
6 tbsp extra virgin olive oil
1 clove garlic 
1 hot chilli pepper
½ tbsp pepper, salt

Method:
Add the tomatoes drained from the oil, egg, olives, parsley, garlic, chilli and the pecorino into a food processor and blend. Place the mixture into a bowl and carefully mix one tbsp of oil at a time and season to taste. Boil your pasta then strain saving 3 tbsp pasta water. Combine the pasta into the bowl with the Etruscan sauce. It’s simple and delicious. For those wanting to ‘cheat’, use this delicious, light and creamy Salsa Etrusca instead.

The wine: 2022 was the 20th harvest of this 100% Sangiovese wine. It’s full of personality with deep aromas of red forest fruits, gentle spice and slightly herbaceous notes. Expect a tannic, surprisingly sweet, intensely fruity red wine followed by the urge to pour another glass… 

The combination: A surprisingly light and creamy sauce with plenty of complexity, just like the red wine it's paired with, the easy-going, delicious summer-berry goodness of this Sangiovese works in perfect harmony with the pasta dish.

ABV: 14%
Size:
750ml
Find here:
£9.40

The Best Pasta Dishes for White Wine

Photo Credit - Fattoria La Vialla Best Pasta and Wine Pairings The Three Drinkers Mini Pasta Salad Vermentino di Maremma Toscana D.O.C..jpg

Eat: Mini Pasta Salad
Drink: Vermentino di Maremma Toscana D.O.C.

Ingredients (Serves 4)
350g mini farfalle
300g fresh green beans
250g cherry tomatoes
200g diced fresh pecorino cheese 
1 jar Pasticcio di Olive
1 bunch chives
2 tbsp extra virgin olive oil
salt 

For the sauce: 
4 tbsp extra virgin olive oil
1 tbsp Balsamico Bianco
1 tsp Pesto al Finocchietto

Method: 
Wash, top and tail the green beans, then boil in a large pot with salted water. Remove the beans after twenty minutes (keep the water) and chop in half. Cook the pasta in the same water and strain once al dente. Transfer to a large bowl, dress with 2 tbsp of olive oil and set aside. In the meantime, wash and chop the cherry tomatoes and chives. 

Now for the sauce! In a bowl, add the olive oil, Balsamico Bianco and Pesto al Finocchietto and stir until smooth. Now simply combine all ingredients into a large bowl and mix well! Season to taste. Rest for half an hour and tuck in!

The wine: Grown just off the coast in the Tuscan Maremma, to preserve the delicate wildflower aromas of this wine made from 100% Vermentino grapes, the bunches of grapes are pressed immediately upon harvesting, right at the vineyard. It’s a beautifully sunny yellow wine that just pops with breezy floral aromas and is endlessly refreshing on the palate with plenty of minerality, and notes of citrus and green apple.

The combination: This is the perfect summer dish - the fennel and olive punch are devilishly moreish, and the refreshing white wine will keep your palate cleansed and ready for more. A must-try for the hottest days of summer! 

ABV: 12.5%
Size:
750ml
Find here:
£8.65

Photo Credit - Fattoria La Vialla Best Pasta and Wine Pairings The Three Drinkers Pici Pasta with Pesto and Peppers Torbolino Non Filtrato 2023.jpg

Eat: Pici Pasta with Pesto and Peppers
Drink: Torbolino Non Filtrato 2023

Ingredients (Serves 6)
500g pici
1 red bell pepper
1 yellow bell pepper 
100g basil
50g pine nuts
50g shelled walnuts
1 clove of garlic 
100g grated pecorino cheese 
8 tbsp extra virgin olive oil
coarse salt

Method: 
Preheat the oven to 200’c (400’F). Whole roast the bell pepper for 10 minutes, then remove and set aside in a food-safe container for a few minutes until cool enough to handle. Remove the core and stem and cut into strips. Add washed basil leaves, pine nuts, walnuts, garlic, olive oil and half of the pecorino into a food processor and blend into a pesto sauce. Cook the Pici in salted water and strain when al dente, keeping some pasta water, then tip into a bowl. In the bowl, add the pesto, peppers, 2 tbsp of the pasta water, and the rest of the pecorino cheese. Garnish with a drizzle of oil and serve up! Bon Appétit!

The wine: A delicate and dry unfiltered ‘Torbolino’, this impressive blend of Chardonnay, Viognier and Sauvignon Blanc come together beautifully to craft a buttery smooth wine. Expect a little sweetness from the unfiltered slowly stirred lees, very little acidity and notes of orchard fruits. 

The combination: The sweet, mellow unfiltered wine enhances the delicate flavours of the dish, marking this perfect ten up to an eleven. If you’re not too sure about unfiltered wine, there is an equally beautiful, filtered version of this Torbolino wine that would pair perfectly with the dish too.

ABV: 13%
Size:
750ml
Find here:
£9.55

Photo Credit - Fattoria La Vialla Best Pasta and Wine Pairings The Three Drinkers Spaghetti with Baked Cherry Tomatoes Pinot Grigio I.G.T. 2022 Unfiltered.jpg

Eat: Spaghetti with Baked Cherry Tomatoes
Drink: Pinot Grigio I.G.T. 2022 Unfiltered

Ingredients (Serves 5-6)
500g Spaghetti
1.2kg “Pachino” cherry tomatoes, firm and well ripened
2 thick slices (2-3 cm) of homemade bread, 2-3 days old
12 tbsp Extra Virgin Olive Oil
150g aged pecorino cheese
2 cloves of garlic
1 sprig of basil leaves
1 tsp dried oregano (or fresh chopped parsley, according to taste) 
salt and pepper

Method: 
Halve the cherry tomatoes and arrange them in a single layer in an oven dish, greased with 3 tbsp of olive oil. Season with salt and pepper, then layer four more tablespoons of oil on top. In a separate bowl, grate the pecorino and bread, add the basil, garlic, oregano and salt and pepper and mix well. Sprinkle the mixture over the tomatoes and top with the remaining oil. 

Cook in the oven for 40 minutes at 180’c (350’F). At the same time, boil your spaghetti until it’s perfectly cooked, then drain and add straight into your roasted tomato mixture and serve as it is. Aromatic and decadent, bellissimo!

The wine: An unusual (but delicious) Pinot Grigio. It’s made from 100% Pinot Grigio grapes, but the interest here lies in the sourcing of these grapes, in that they come from two vineyards with vastly different terroir, climate conditions and even age. The two grapes balance delicately into a wine that has the fragrance of a well-kept orchard with layered notes of camomile and peach. On first sip, expect a lighter wine with floral and dried fruit notes.

The combination: This dish has been paired with a stunning, light, fruity and almost sweet Pinot Grigio. It’s low acidity contrasts beautifully with the rich cheese and tomato offering on your plate for a match made in heaven!

ABV: 14%
Size:
750ml
Find here:
£9.60

The Best Pasta Dishes for Sparkling Wine

Photo Credit - Fattoria La Vialla Best Pasta and Wine Pairings The Three Drinkers Spaghetti with Basil Pesto and Confit Cherry Tomatoes Cuvée Rosé Millesimato Brut 2019, Traditional Method, Unfiltered

Eat: Spaghetti with Basil Pesto and Confit Cherry Tomatoes
Drink: Cuvée Rosé Millesimato Brut 2019, Traditional Method, Unfiltered

Ingredients (Serves 4-5)
500g spaghetti
500g cherry tomatoes
4 tbsp extra virgin olive oil
25g sugar
1 clove of garlic
10 sprigs of thyme
1 tsp oregano 
salt and pepper

For the pesto:
100g basil 
60g parmigiano 
40g aged pecorino cheese 
50g pine nuts 
1 clove of garlic 
½ glass extra virgin olive oil 
1 tsp salt

Method: 
Wash and halve the tomatoes, place cut-side-up in a lined baking tray and season with salt and pepper. Peel the garlic and finely chop the thyme sprigs along with oregano. Mix and season each tomato with the herb mix. On each tomato, add a pinch of sugar and a drizzle of oil. Place in the oven and cook at 140’c (275’F) for two hours - patience is key. While it’s cooking, prepare your pesto! Crush the pine nuts until smooth, then chop the garlic, pecorino, parmigiano and toss with salt. Combine with the pine nut mixture and add the oil, a little at a time until thick. Cook the spaghetti al dente and save the pasta water. Once strained, add the spaghetti and pesto sauce to a frying pan on a very low heat. Add a spoonful of pasta water and toss until everything is mixed. Serve immediately, garnished with the beautifully slow cooked confit tomatoes! 

The wine: This sparkling rosé, produced in the same way as champagne, is 100% hand-picked Pinot Nero, and it is so, so aromatic due to its unfiltered nature. The colour in the glass evokes a picturesque sunset and there’s even more romance to be found when you try it. On the nose, there are crisp raspberry aromas and a savoury note that will remind you of freshly baked brioche. There’s more where that came from on the palate; dry, red berries and a hint of dark chocolate. If you’ve not been sure about sparkling rosé in the past, this might just change your mind!

The combination: Caramelised tomatoes are a real labour of love and patience - just like this sparkling rosé, which was aged for 40 months in the bottle! The dish is surprisingly low acidity, which is perfect because you’ll get all you need from this top-quality sparkling rosé wine.

ABV: 12.5%
Size:
750ml
Find here:
£21.95

Now you know how to pair wine and pasta, and have some great recommendations on where to start, what are you waiting for? Jump in the kitchen, get creative and above all, enjoy delicious wine and pasta! For many more tasty pasta and wine pairings, look no further than here and for anyone who is vegetarian, you can easily make and enjoy the above wine and pasta combinations by swapping out the cheese for a vegetarian variety. Saluti!

By Miley Kendrick

With thanks to Fattoria La Vialla for providing the images used in this article.

Miley Kendrick

Miley fell head over heels for bartending the second she stepped behind a bar at the young age of eighteen, where she underwent about the most intense training possible from old school cocktail bar, Be at One. Slinging drinks is a natural fit for a musician and frontwoman, providing a stage to be herself, create, and be playful. Since making the move to independent bars in 2021, Miley has won two UK cocktail competitions and competed on a global scale in Sweden and Mexico. Everything Miley does is a means to creating the most whimsical life possible for herself; her drive to fill her world with art fuels her passion for writing, crafting cocktails, or playing guitar.