Is Lighter Rosé Better than Darker? With Recommendations!

is lighter rosé better than darker? with recommendations! the three drinkers

What is Rosé?

Rosé sits somewhere between red and white wine, usually with red fruit flavours and notes of florality and citrus – though of course it varies! Celery, melon, rhubarb, they’re all common notes in Rosé too.

Where red wine ferments for weeks with red grape skins, Rosé only touches them for 2-20 hours. Thus, they are stained red but not completely! Any red grape can be used for this, but preferred varietals tend to be Pinot Noir, Grenache, Syrah, Sangiovese, and Zinfandel. The main way Rosé is made is that during the maceration of the grapes, the skins from the red grapes sit within the juices and the longer they remain like that, the redder it becomes.

The less common method, the Saignée method, is to take the red wine-making process and bleed off a proportion of it before it’s had too much contact with the red grape skins. However, there is another way, and it’s probably the way most people assume it’s made…

It’s pretty much only the Champagne region that does this, but you can make Rosé by adding red wine into vats of white wine (usually only 5% red). They use reds from the south and whites from the north to create these blends of fine wine, but you’ll almost never find this method outside of Champagne.

Each winemaker can decide when to remove their wine from the red grape skins depending on what their aims are for the wine. But, with so many different shades of Rosé, is one better than the other?

Is lighter Rosé better than darker Rosé?

is lighter rosé better than darker? with recommendations! the three drinkers

In a word, no. From super pale hues to salmon pink, right through to deep ruby, you will find quality Rosé throughout the Rosé rainbow. That’s not to say there isn’t a difference though. Generally speaking, lighter rosé is dryer and less sweet, whilst darker wines are sweeter and full-bodied – but this isn’t a hard and fast rule.

Several factors affect the colour. Some grapes used are simply darker than others, the time spent with the oak, and crucially, the amount of contact with the grape skins.

The idea that paler blends are better may have come about alongside the increased popularity of this dry Provence style, and the decreased interest in the old style, but with so much variation, you can’t judge a Rosé by the colour! You can by the taste however, and these are five examples that pass that particular test with flying pink colours!

5 bottles of Rosé to try

ARGENTINA

Susana Balbo Signature Rose 2019

susana balbo rose is lighter rosé better than darker? with recommendations! the three drinkers

Susana Balbo is an absolute legend of winemaking, becoming not just the first female winemaker in Argentina but creating one of the most respected wineries in the world. This Provencal-style Rosé has a terrific balance of zesty citrus and red berries, with a wonderfully elegant and delicate feel. The touch of acidity is very welcome too, and overall this is a seriously well-put-together, well-balanced Rosé.

Size: 750ml
ABV: 13%
Find here: £18.60

ITALY

Principato Pinot Grigio Rosato 2022

principato pinot grigio rosato is lighter rosé better than darker? with recommendations! the three drinkers

Italian Rosé, or ‘Rosato’ tends to provide fantastic value, case in point being this juicy and aromatic number from Lombardia. It’s noticeably crisp and refreshing, with delicious strawberry and white peach notes. Super drinkable with a moreish lightness, and perfect for those wanting to avoid overly sweet Rosé expressions.

Size: 750ml
ABV: 12%
Find here: £8.50

SPAIN

Bodegas Ameztoi Txakoli de Getaria Rubentis Rosado 2022

ameztoi txakoli rubentis rose is lighter rosé better than darker? with recommendations! the three drinkers

This Basque Rosé is made using two grapes you won’t often see in Rosé, a half-and-half mix of Hondarribi Beltza and Hondarribi Zuri. A tasty food-friendly expression, behind that inviting pale pink hue are aromas of ripe red fruit with a familiar combination of citrus and floral notes. The fresh and fruity palate opens up to some zippy acidity and pleasant minerality that really is delicious.

Size: 750ml
ABV: 11%
Find here: £14.80

PORTUGAL

Titan of Douro Reserve Rosé 2019

titan of duoro rose is lighter rosé better than darker? with recommendations! the three drinkers

Rich with mouth-watering sweet peach and cherry, the burst of lemon and tang of raspberry offsets wonderfully well. There is even a touch of smoke and warmth that comes through, but it retains a complete vibrance and freshness. If you want to taste something a little different to your usual Rosé then this is most certainly it.

Size: 750ml
ABV: 13.5%
Find here: £16.93

FRANCE

Marcel Martin La Jaglerie Rosé d'Anjou 2021

is lighter rosé better than darker? with recommendations! the three drinkers marcel martin la jagliere rose d'anjou

Red fruits and florality flood the nose of this Cabernet Franc/Grolleau French Rosé, which for this price point is a must. Hailing from the Loire region, the balance of French rose, strawberries, raspberries, and even subtle pastry notes is in perfect harmony. A benchmark fresh, medium dry and smooth French Rosé that will never disappoint.

Size: 750ml
ABV: 11%
Find here: £9.49

 

Rosé in the sun is unbeatable stuff, but if you’re cutting out the booze then check out these Stunning No-Lo Drinks for Summer!