Over the many years people have been imbibing, cocktail trends have come, gone, and come again multiple times. Throughout these cycles, and the memory obscuring nature of alcoholic beverages playing its role, many a mixed drink has slipped through the cracks into relative obscurity. This is not to say the drink is bad, however, as they were thoroughly enjoyed in their heyday. In fact, if every drink that fell out of fashion was in fact unenjoyable, then personalities like renowned cocktail historian Harry Craddock would become obsolete, and we could not be happier that this is not the case.
Craddock and co’s work allows home cocktail enthusiasts and professional bartenders alike to rediscover some of the best drinks of generations past. It often begs the question “How did this drink even fall out of fashion in the first place?”
In honour of our beloved historians, let us look at some classic cocktails that enjoyed the spotlight some years ago, but rarely see play in the bars of today.
ALAMAGOOZLUM
Similar to many American classic cocktails of its era, this cocktail's time and place accreditations are muddy. However, while we may not know who created it, it was popularised by John Pierpoint Morgan Sr. more popularly known as J.P. Morgan.
Like the cocktail, the word Alamagoozlum itself has unclear origins, with some sources stating it to be a stand-in for doohickey or thingamabob, while others claim it to be a French-Canadian-American term for maple syrup.
What can be said for sure is that the drink is just as unique as its namesake. Created by the founder of a worldwide financial conglomerate, it initially served as a batched punch recipe to serve five cocktails. It also has the oddity of being shaken with an egg white despite a distinct lack of citrus and all other ingredients being spirits, liqueurs, or bitters. Normally, a drink with such a recipe would be stirred over ice.
This cocktail is not one for the faint of heart either, with punchy ingredients such as genever and Jamaican pot still rum forming the base, and seasoned with healthy pours of Yellow Chartreuse and Angostura bitters. If sweet and herbaceous sounds like a little bit of you we recommend giving this one a go!
Ingredients
20ml Genever
15ml Jamaican Pot Still Rum
15ml Yellow Chartreuse
5ml Orange Curacao
5ml Angostura Bitters
10ml 2:1 Simple Syrup (15ml if using 1:1 Simple)
20ml Water (Trust me)
15ml Egg Whites or foamer of choice
Method
Combine all ingredients into a shaker tin. Shake without ice, and then with ice. Strain into a cocktail coupe. Garnish with a pineapple wedge.
DEATH IN THE AFTERNOON
Contrary to popular belief, this drink is not named after the Ernest Hemingway novel, it was created by the man himself. The original drink called for “1 jigger (45ml) of absinthe” and “iced champagne until it attains the proper opalescent milkiness.” As we are well aware, Hemingway was not a man for just one casual drink, his instructions state to “Drink 3 to 5 of these slowly.”
Like many Hemingway cocktails, the modern spec had to be adjusted to suit the palate of today, as his spirit-forward, zero-sugar approach results in a harshly dry, unpleasing drinking experience. Even with the toned-down pour, and a splash of sugar, the drink remains absinthe forward, with rich notes of anise and candied fennel seeds in the spotlight. The sharp acidity and brioche/biscuit notes of the champagne add a reprieve from the potency of the absinthe, and the lemon twist garnish adds a lingering freshness to the nose. We would not recommend having 3 to 5 of these, but we recommend one!
Ingredients
10ml Absinthe
5ml 2:1 Simple Syrup (7.5ml if using 1:1 Simple Syrup)
Top with Champagne
Method
Combine absinthe and simple syrup in a mixing tin and stir until cold. Strain into a champagne flute. Top with champagne. Garnish with lemon zest.
SATURN
This gin-based tiki drink with a storied history gives rum a run for its money. Created by California bartender, J. “Popo” Galsini, it was originally called the X-15, after an American rocket-powered aircraft. However, the drink required a change of name as shortly after the advent of the drink, an X-15 pilot suffered a fatal crash. Galsini renamed the drink Saturn after the rocket of the first Apollo space flight.
Under the name Saturn, Galsini submitted the drink to the International Bartender’s Association World Championship in 1967, in which he placed first. The drink enjoyed its moment in the spotlight during the tiki boom in mid-century America, after which it faded into obscurity, and would more than likely have been lost forever were it not for famed tiki cocktail historian Jeff “Beachbum” Berry. Berry came across a commemorative glass in a thrift shop in Southern California, and opted not to purchase it, but took a picture of the recipe listed on the glass, and then included it in his recipe book “Beachbum Berry Remixed”.
This publication caused a mild resurgence of the cocktail and can now be seen in the deep cuts of cocktail bars. Much like the Pina Colada, the Saturn falls into the category of can be shaken but is much better blended. The rich tropical combination of Falernum, Orgeat, and Passionfruit syrup gives this drink unmatchable crushability making it easy to see off multiple in one sitting. The drink is traditionally garnished with a cherry and lemon peel on a cocktail skewer resembling Saturn and its rings, however, for ease of recreation, a simple cherry and lemon wedge will suffice.
Method
Combine all ingredients in a blender. Blend with ice until slushy. Served in a sling glass. Garnish with a cherry and lemon slice.
OR
Combine all ingredients in a shaker tin. Shake over ice. Strain into a highball glass filled with crushed ice. Garnish with a cherry and lemon slice.
ANGEL FACE
This pre-prohibition cocktail comes from Harry Craddock’s “The Savoy Cocktail Book” with little else other than a recipe. Many have tried to use external sources to find out more about the origin of this drink but to no avail.
A lack of history does not make this drink any less delicious though. A simple foolproof recipe of three ingredients in equal parts brilliantly displays the keystone bartending principle of simplicity in execution and complexity in flavour. The original recipe calls for the drink to be shaken, and modern bartenders will tell you it should be stirred, however, my preferred serve is to combine all three ingredients with water for dilution and store in the freezer beforehand. This results in a drink with the appropriate amount of dilution and a rich silky texture which matches the flavour of the drink itself.
This is a rich, sweet, spirit-forward cocktail and makes an excellent summer sipper for Manhattan drinkers. Rich apple and apricot notes star on the palate with seasonings being offered from the botanicals of the gin.
Ingredients
25ml London Dry Gin
25ml Calvados
25ml Apricot Brandy
Method
Combine all ingredients in a mixing tin. Stir over ice. Strain into a cocktail glass. Garnish with a lemon twist or apple slice.
LA LOUISIANE
With a name like this, it comes as no surprise that this classic cocktail originated from the French quarter of New Orleans. This drink was the signature cocktail of Restaurant de la Louisiane, one of the hallmark French restaurants of New Orleans.
The modern recipe is an adaptation of the one listed in Stanley Clisby Arthur’s 1937 publication “Famous New Orleans Drinks and How to Mix ‘Em” and has the distinctive DNA of a Manhattan - Rye Whiskey and Sweet Vermouth, alongside various modifiers. These modifiers include Benedictine, Absinthe, and Peychauds Bitters, resulting in a sweeter take on a timeless classic a rich herbaceous character.
This cocktail serves as an excellent alternative to the classic Manhattan for the winter months as the Benedictine offers a lovely warmth, with the Peychauds bringing a complex winter spice character.
Similar to the aforementioned Angel Face, this is another cocktail viable in the freezer-door category. Precombining all the ingredients with 10% of the total volume in water, and storing it in the freezer for later drinking makes for easy drinking after a long shift, or good for serving a large crowd without having to remove yourself from the social for too long.
Ingredients
30ml Bottled-in-Bond Rye Whiskey
30ml Sweet Vermouth (Ideally Italian)
15ml Benedictine D.O.M.
2.5ml Absinthe
2 Dashes Peychaud’s Bitters
Method
Combine all ingredients in a mixing tin. Stir over ice. Strain into a Nick & Nora Glass. Garnish with a cherry.
CULROSS
Yet another drink with an unknown origin, this cocktail is named after the Scottish village and former royal burgh, Culross. The earliest documentation of this drink comes from the bible of forgotten classic cocktails; Harry Craddock’s “The Savoy Cocktail Book”. This cocktail calls for Kina Lillet in the original recipe but has since stopped production and is no longer available. As a substitute, we recommend Lillet Blanc or Bordiga Vermut Bianco.
The drink is dry, and lightly sour with a rich fruity backbone owing to the aromatised wine and Apricot Brandy. The rum comes in the mid-palate to bring an alcoholic punch, and the touch of lemon juice brings much-needed freshness to the drink.
Ingredients
30ml Light Rum
30ml Apricot Brandy
30ml Blanc Vermouth
7.5ml Lemon Juice
Method
Combine all ingredients in a shaker tin. Shake with ice. Strain into a cocktail coupe. Garnish with an orange zest.
DAISY DE SANTIAGO
This summer refresher is an adapted recipe from Charles H. Baker Jr.’s book “The Gentleman’s Companion Volume II - An Exotic Drinking Book” (1939). The passage it is mentioned in states that it was served in a special skyscraper the Bacardi distillery had erected in Cuba, where they would invite various travellers to come and imbibe various Bacardi-based cocktails. The passage also states that this cocktail is “along with the immortal Daiquiri, …. The best Bacardi drink on record.”
The drink reads as a potent variation of the Canchanchara - a daiquiri with honey as opposed to sugar syrup. The Yellow Chartreuse adds rich honey sweetness and complexity from its proprietary blend of botanicals, with the rum and lemon juice forming the main flavour profile of the drink.
Ingredients
60ml Light Rum
22.5ml Lemon Juice
7.5ml Yellow Chartreuse
7.5ml 2:1 Simple Syrup (10ml if using 1:1 Simple Syrup)
5ml Yellow Chartreuse to float on top
Method
Combine all ingredients except the last 5ml of Yellow Chartreuse in a shaker tin. Shake over ice. Strain into a highball glass filled with crushed ice. Garnish with Yellow Chartreuse float, seasonal berries, and a mint sprig.
By Fowwaz Ansari
