The Best Whiskey for Irish Coffee

Winter warmer season is in full swing, and wrapping your hands around an Irish Coffee warms the body and soul like little else... but only if the whiskey is spot on. Whilst they’re super easy to make, picking the ideal whiskey for however you like your Irish Coffee is the most important part, so pick your star of the show from the list below!

Powers

Dating back to a staggering 1791, Powers is the traditionalist’s whiskey option for their Irish Coffee. It’s got great complexity for the under £30 price point that will add layers to your coffee and keep it interesting until the end. It’s really smooth with gorgeous buttery shortbread notes, caramel and even a hint of chocolate adding to the indulgent experience.

Size: 700ml
ABV: 40%
Find here: £27.90

Jameson Stout Edition

Jameson tops the sales charts for Irish whiskey across the globe and whilst their original is a fantastic beginner’s option for Irish Coffee, their stout-seasoned barrel-aged edition is a level up. Alongside the signature easy-drinking smoothness and subtle fruitiness we expect from Jameson, this innovative mix boasts lingering chocolate, coffee and butterscotch notes that are dying to be the star of your next Irish Coffee.

Size: UK 700ml // US 750ml
ABV: 40%    
Find here: UK £23.99 / US $36.99

Slane Whiskey

Slane is stunning for the price with the perfect balance of spice and sweetness. Three different casks are used (seasoned casks containing bourbon, sherry and oak) to create a really full and satisfying taste, with rounded buttery vanilla notes. There are also hints of baking spice so it’s ideal for an Irish Coffee with a bit of heat behind the heat if you know what we mean. Indulgence in a mug!

Size: UK 700ml // US 750ml
ABV: 40%
Find here: UK £24.45 // US $32.99

Kilbeggan Irish Whiskey

For just over £20, Kilbeggan is steadfast and reliable for an Irish Coffee. Smooth, light and more noticeably, it’s distilled twice rather than three times over so retains earthy peaty qualities that will go perfectly with certain coffees. Kilbeggan is named after one of the 12 Apostles of Ireland and the distillery itself is claimed to be the oldest of its type in the entire country, so it’s a taste of history too.

Size: UK 700ml // US 750ml
ABV: 40%
Find here: UK £22.44 / US $35.99

Roe and Co

Matured exclusively in ex-bourbon barrels and a blended mix of single malt and grain whiskeys, this Master award winning expression is spot on for an Irish Coffee with full and deep flavours. There’s creaminess, velvet texture, lofty notes of spiced pears, mellow vanilla and toasted oak that feels perfectly rich and warming for winter.  

Size: UK 700ml // US 750ml
ABV: 45%
Find here: UK £31.95 // US $38.99

Teeling Small Batch Whiskey

This is another whiskey that has a Master award sitting in its cabinet, but it’s more unusual. The malt and grain blend matures in ex-bourbon but is then moved to rum casks for a whole year before being bottled without chill-filtration. The texture is super smooth and behind that is bold flavouring that you can bet won’t die in the heat. Fruitiness from the rum entangles with vanilla and caramel cream for a wonderfully rich and varied palate. Combined with the coffee, there will be serious flavours happening so it’s got to be worth seeing if you love it.   

Size: UK 700ml // US 750ml
ABV: 46%
Find here: UK £36.95 // US $39.99

The Sexton Single Malt

Sexton is the go-to Irish Coffee whiskey for quite a few bartenders and that’s because of the delicious and authentic flavour. Made from 100% malted barley and triple distilled in copper pot stills, it’s then aged in Oloroso sherry casks imparting an inviting fruitiness. Vanilla, dried fruits and honeycomb sweetness are bold but restrained in the right places. The only negative is that the gorgeous vintage bottle makes it difficult to see how much you’re getting through, and when you take your first sip, you’ll see why that may present an issue.

Size: UK 700ml // US 750ml
ABV: 40%
Find here: UK £30 // US $29.99

Sliabh Liag Silkie Blended Irish Whiskey

The Silkies of Irish legend are seals that shapeshifted into irresistible beings on land, and it looks like some of them then transformed into whiskey bottles too because this is just as irresistible. Made in Donegal at the relatively new Sliabh Liag distillery, it is fruity and balanced with precision. From apricot on the nose, to honey on the palate and toasted caramel on the finish, there’s a sweet vein running throughout but it’s surrounded by plenty of character and intrigue that will easily shine through a hot Irish Coffee.

Size: UK 700ml
ABV: 46%
Find here: £30.45

Green Spot Single Pot Irish Still Whiskey

This is a fabulous single pot still whiskey that’s been impressing critics for some time. Bourbon and then sherry casks create an enchanting nose of apple, malt, sugary porridge, creamy vanilla and tropical fruits, which opens up to a soft and spicy palate that feels interestingly fragrant yet woody. Far from being a whiskey that drags its feet, this is super light and complex and perfect for a sophisticated and endlessly rewarding Irish Coffee.

Size: UK 700ml // US 750ml
ABV: 40%
Find here: UK £39.99/ US $76.99

If you’re looking for the perfect Irish Coffee recipes, look no further, we’ve done the hard work for you!

6 Irish Coffee Recipes for All Whiskey Lovers

The season of cosy cocktails is upon us, and the Irish Coffee has to be right at the top of that list. Rich, warming and velvety smooth, it’s simply perfect as the nights draw in.  

They’re so simple to make, but that doesn’t mean you can’t vary it up! Picking the perfect whiskey can transform an Irish Coffee, so take a look at our favourites below. Richer, spicier, fruitier, whatever your preference it’s here.

Traditional Irish Coffee- Powers

If you want to taste Irish Coffee as it was originally intended, then this traditional recipe is the way to go because it’s exactly the way that Chef Joe Sheridan made it back in 1943, at Foynes Airport. It’s also the method that we follow in Episode 2 of The Three Drinkers in Ireland if you want to find out more! At the centre of it is Powers, a classic Irish whiskey that’s been around since 1791! This concoction is a true taste of history.

Ingredients
2 teaspoons brown sugar
120ml hot coffee
45ml Powers Irish whiskey
Cream lightly whipped

Method
First, warm your glass with hot water for a little bit (make sure you tip it out) before adding the sugar and then the beautiful steaming coffee. Add the Irish whiskey, and pour that silky very lightly whipped cream on top over the back of a spoon – this way it sits beautifully on top! As they say in Ireland, Slainte!

Fruity Irish Coffee - Jameson

Jameson is the biggest selling Irish whiskey in the world and for good reason. Deemed by many as the ultimate beginner’s dram, it has more pronounced sweeter notes with apples, honey and tropical fruits coming to the fore, rather than spice or smoke which can be more challenging. This is perfect for a really tasty and subtly fruity Irish Coffee to warm you on a cold night. 

Ingredients
30ml cream
10ml demerara sugar syrup
90ml espresso
35ml Jameson Original
Grated nutmeg (garnish)
1 vanilla pod (garnish)

Method
The sugar syrup is so simple to make, just dissolve demerara sugar in boiling water, and stir this into your measure of Jameson. Add the espresso shots. Then, whip the cream a little to stiffen it and pour it over the back of a spoon so it sits nicely on top. Garnish with a dusting of nutmeg or cinnamon and a vanilla pod for a drink that looks and tastes stunning.

Spicier Irish Coffee - Slane

Slane Irish Whiskey is made from not one, not two but three different casks – virgin oak, Sherry, and seasoned casks which previously contained Tennessee whiskey and bourbon. The end result is a really full taste, with flavours of butterscotch and vanilla, as well as warming notes of baking spice. It’s ideal for a spicier and particularly Autumnal Irish Coffee.

Ingredients
40ml Slane Irish Whiskey
15ml vanilla-infused demerara syrup
70ml espresso
20ml double cream
Dark chocolate shavings (garnish)

Method
Half fill your glass with boiling water and add syrup, coffee, and whiskey. The syrup can be made by combining boiling water, demerara, and vanilla essence or pods. Top with the lightly stiffened double cream float (again, using the back of the spoon) and finish with chocolate shavings. This is pure indulgence and the perfect balance of sugar and spice.

Peaty Irish Coffee - Kilbeggan

Now, this is a whiskey steeped in history. It’s named after one of the Twelve Apostles of Ireland who founded a monastery nearby in the 6th century, and the Kilbeggan Distillery itself is the oldest of its kind in Ireland. It’s distilled twice rather than thrice, so retains strong peaty qualities and a long finish full of flavour.

Ingredients
15ml cream
15ml brown sugar syrup
90ml coffee
40ml Kilbeggan Single Grain Irish Whiskey
Grated nutmeg (garnish)

Method
Add your Kilbeggan and brown sugar syrup to the glass (to make this heat sugar to water in a 2:1 ratio until the sugar dissolves). Fill up with coffee and cover the top with a small amount of cream. Grate some gorgeous nutmeg to finish and voila!

Rich Irish Coffee – Roe And Co

Roe and Co have been on our lips since scooping the prestigious Master award at the Irish Whiskey Masters in 2019. It’s a beautifully balanced whiskey with creaminess, a velvety texture and notes of woody vanilla and spiced pears. Worryingly moreish and one you definitely have to try! Why not in a Irish Coffee?

Ingredients
40ml Roe & Co
75ml hot coffee
1 tsp demerara sugar
20ml double cream
Grated nutmeg (garnish)

Method
Super simple this one. Just add everything but the cream and stir well to dissolve the sugar. Then spoon over the gently whipped double cream on top and grate some nutmeg to finish. It’s luxuriously rich and fulfilling to the max.

Super Smooth Irish Coffee- Teeling

We bring you another Master winner, this time from 2020 and it’s Teeling’s glorious Small Batch. The blend of malt and grain whiskeys is aged in ex-Bourbon barrels initially, before unconventionally being moved for further ageing in Central American rum barrels. Because of this, it’s fruity on the nose, super smooth on the palate and finishes with an enticing caramel creaminess. The combination of rum and whiskey creates a unique flavour profile that you may well fall in love with! 

Ingredients
40ml Teeling Small Batch
80ml brown sugar syrup (50/50 split)
120ml coffee
20ml double cream

Method
Word to the wise, the sugar syrup here is a 50/50 split of sugar and hot water, which is less sugary than usual, in case you were thinking 80ml is a lot! Preheat your glass and add the whiskey, syrup, and freshly brewed coffee. Stir thoroughly and pour the cream over the back of a spoon. Again, grate some nutmeg if it suits your tastes and away you go!

If all that has got you in the mood for other coffee cocktails, then check out our best selections here. And for more great Irish Whiskey content, explore our other favourites with, ‘The Best Irish Whiskey’.

Words by Calum Ecroyd