There's chatter all over the beverage world about a Chartreuse shortage. Chartreuse is a potent liqueur available in two iterations - Green, a strong and powerful version, and Yellow, a sweeter and lighter version - made of a secret concoction of herbs, spices, honey, and bittering elements still meticulously hand measured and produced in a Carthusian monastery in the mountains of south-eastern France.
Due to a global interest in more complicated cocktails, a rise in the popularity of herbaceous flavours, and the increased demand for many specific modern classic recipes, demand for Chartreuse has increased in recent years. But, because of its small-scale production - ironically, one of its most exciting selling points - demand has recently been exceeding supply. This has made it difficult for many bars and cocktail enthusiasts to order or stock the popular liqueur. Many sites suggest general, herbal and floral alternatives but the uniqueness of Chartreuse comes from the alpine flavours highlighted with bittersweet backing. This list will get you closer than any other list because it focuses on the herbaceous, alpine nature of the popular spirit and will get you closer to the flavours of the original for use in beloved classics or brand new mixtures. Below is just a selection of where to start when trying to find Chartreuse substitutes.
Metté Liqueur de Bourgeons de Sapin (Tree Buds)
Alpine flavours are rare in the UK. Though these sap and tree liqueurs are extremely popular in southern Europe, that flavour profile hasn't yet made it to the British Isles in staggering quantities. Whether it's blamed on the smaller amount of mountainous regions, unexplored flavour diversity, or simply an undereducated consumer base, there just aren't as many options for UK residents as there are in other countries around the world. Luckily, this liqueur is doing its best to offer an entry gateway into alpine flavours. It is sweet, it is greenish in the bottle, and it has beautiful notes of forest fauna and The powerful and unique Alpine flavour that makes it work in place of Chartreuse in cocktails.
Size: 350ml
ABV: 25%
Find here: £19.04
Distillerie de Grandmont Le Chemin Des Moines Liqueur
This liqueur wins the nomination for balance when it comes to replacing Chartreuse and cocktails. It won't be the most Alpine, but it also won't be the most floral. It won't be as strong as Chartreuse, but it won't be so light that it would need some support from a stronger spirit. It is strong enough to offer some backbone to the cocktail just like Chartreuse does, and also has quite a bit of honey character. It is floral, but has a bright grassy flavour that hints toward the mountainous blend used by the monks. The bitterness cuts through the sweetness more so, making it a bit less pleasant as a neat serve or on the rocks. But that's not usually how Chartreuse is enjoyed either. It brings a light root spice character which will complement any savoury elements to any modern or classic cocktail.
Size: 700ml
ABV: 55%
Find here: £44.45
Cappelletti Amaro Alta Verde
This pale green color amaro is a perfect substitute for when Chartreuse isn't available, and confusingly not mentioned on any other list of substitutes or alternatives. It's hard to imagine why this might be for many global publications. For The Three Drinkers, it is recommended with one unfortunate caveat. The liqueur is usually available all throughout the US through a magnificent importer, but seemingly only available in Europe where it is produced in Italy. That being said, it is only a widely accessible option for some readers. Though it is so delicious, it might be worth planning an Italian holiday. The light natural colour breaks the mould for amari in the marketplace, while also making it a perfect alternative to Chartreuse in flavour and presentation of the cocktail colour. The bitterness comes from a wormwood varietal which balances out sweet and citrus flavours. It has heaps of Alpine, it is versatile and adaptive depending upon the cocktail recipe or ingredients it is paired alongside.
Size: 750ml
ABV: 24%
Find here: $29.99
Amaro Pasubio
Another gem from the house of Cappelletti, Pasubio is a mountainous blend of fruit and herbaceous while being a controversial addition to this list only on the colour consideration of Chartreuse substitutes. Pasubio is a maceration of many plants and roots mixed with mountain blueberries. The colour, therefore, is a dark brownish purple. While this can be gorgeous and magnificent in many things, many cocktails calling for Chartreuse are banking on the bold green and yellow colours to enhance the drinker's experience. In this case, the visual experience will be slightly muddied. Another unique consideration for adding this spirit as an alternative is the strength period rolling in at 17%, it is not going to bring the spirituous nature that Chartreuse drinkers are looking for. In this case, then, it would be beneficial to fortify it with a stronger spirit as the base or simply more of the bass spirit to provide the balance of strength. Though not the easiest replacement, bold intense alpine flavours and the unique addition of the forest fruits will offer immediate solace to anyone enjoying the cocktail.
Size: 750ml
ABV: 17%
Find here: $24
Génépi des Pères Chartreux
Finally, if finding Chartreuse is proving impossible, but you want something with a similar herb blend, this is the spirit for you. It's made by the same monks in the same monastery, so it will have a very similar blend of herbs and botanicals. Though genepy liqueurs are generally softer and very much more floral, this one gets as close to the herb structure as any on the market. In order for the herbs to come through in the same way, A larger amount must be used. For longer cocktails, or bigger glasses, this could bring some of the herbs you're wanting from the mountainous region.
Size: 700ml
ABV: 40%
Find here: £33.95
The earthy, natural, vegetal, and bittersweet flavours of Chartreuse may not always be readily available to order directly from the source. Luckily, there are lots of options that can be combined to get an alpine touch or the green boozy boost that many exciting modern cocktails require. This list is by no means comprehensive, but definitely a strong start and a guide to many new fascinating flavours.
By Zach Sapato
