Nothing screams beach day more than the popular party cocktail, the Piña Colada. But this absurdly tropical drink has much more to it than just refreshing and delicious flavours. The preparation of this traditionally blended cocktail can be quite involved, and without a hotel bar team at your disposal, recreating these tropical vibes at home can be a daunting task. However, there are some cheats, tricks, and alternatives to creating all the complexity of the original without having to clean all the parts of a blender afterwards. If you can't make it to an island and stay in a fancy hotel to have this drink made for you, The Three Drinkers team is here to help with some history and some at-home beach party hacks and recipes.
THE HISTORY of the Piña Colada
The disputed history of the Piña Colada is thought to have started with a recipe adaptation from a Puerto Rican bartender. The most widely accepted story is that bartender Ramón "Monchito" Marrero created this cocktail by adding the increasingly popular canned coconut cream into a Cuban cocktail called Strained Pineapple - a combination of strained pineapple juice, rum, and lime. Strained Pineapple might not ring many bells for non-Spanish speakers but the Spanish word for pineapple is "Piña" and strained is "Colada."
The most important ingredient is a can of coconut cream which played a part in helping pull the tiny island nation first out of poverty and then into karaoke machines around the world. Though coconut cream was being used in many Puerto Rican recipes, the creation and preparation of this ingredient at home was labour intensive. Enter Ramón López Irizarry, an agricultural professor, with his invention Coco Lopez - an emulsion of coconut cream, sugar, and stabilizers. The mass production of this and global popularity of the cocktail gave the country resources to carry it parallel to the global industrialisation happening at the time. This was also an easy to work with and widely available locally produced product which made it the perfect thing to PuertoRicanise, an already touted tropical tipple.
The new and improved Piña Colada was in fact so well-received, it became the national cocktail of Puerto Rico in 1978 and gained global sensation status in the 1979 hit song "Escape" by Rupert Holmes which is always listed with a parenthetical of "(The Piña Colada Song)" in the title.
The traditional Piña Colada cocktail
Ingredients
60ml rum
30ml Coco Lopez
30ml heavy cream
180ml pineapple juice
½ cup crushed ice
Method
Add all ingredients into blender and blend for 15 seconds. Pour into hurricane glass. Garnish with pineapple wedge.
Piña Colada HACKS
Just about any coconut cream will suffice for an at home Piña Colada, but Coco Lopez is the best choice because it already includes sugar. Most other coconut milks will need added sugar and will fall out of solution meaning they will settle at the bottom of the cocktail. So, while other coconut milks and creams may be more readily available, they will not work as well in any cocktail. Coco Lopez is available easily online, both in the US and the UK, so using this in any of these alternatives is going to make a more traditional, better performing, and better tasting cocktail.
Piña Highball-ada
Though no substitute would claim to come close to the OG blender banger, sometimes you find yourself in a corner shop craving a tropical treat to make at home. This alternative uses just three ingredients that are available in almost every store.
Ingredients
25ml pineapple rum
25ml coconut rum/liqueur
110ml coconut water
Method
Build all ingredients into highball glass with ice. Swirl to combine. No garnish required.
CocoPiña Daiquiri
The Piña Colada origins are possibly based on a variation of a Cuban Daiquiri made with added pineapple juice, it is possible to reverse engineer that recipe to create a version made more simply at home with three ingredients that drinks a bit lighter and is more balanced. This cocktail will be delightful to guests looking for a not so sweet alternative. It works for hosts as it requires less planning and purchasing, is faster to create, and is a delightful treat nonetheless.
Ingredients
50ml pineapple rum
30ml Coco Lopez
20ml lime juice
Method
Add all ingredients into cocktail shaker with ice. Shake & fine strain into coupe glass.
BONUS - Piña Co-Lager
As an added bonus, this final cocktail is less of a hack and more of a wild innovation and adaptation, named with an unbeatable pun. Leave it to none other than the Scots to come up with a dangerously punchy Piña Colada that not only includes scotch and beer, but is even more fun to say than the original. It’s created by the staff at The Gate, Glasgow - led by Ally Shaw!
Ingredients
35ml scotch
15ml coconut rum
25ml rum
10ml sugar syrup
50ml pineapple juice
Top w/ lager (preferred: Tennents)
Method
Add the first 5 ingredients into a cocktail shaker with ice. Shake & fine strain into highball glass. Garnish with pineapple leaf.
The Piña Colada stands as an icon of tropical concoctions, blending history with technology to transport imbibers to sunny shores. From local origins in Puerto Rico, where innovation and necessity gave rise to the beloved Coco Lopez, to global acclaim catalyzed by pop culture, this cocktail has become synonymous with summer holidays and escapist moments. While traditional creations are still available where they make the classic blender concoction, modern adaptations and hacks allow enthusiasts to enjoy the fantasy in simpler ways. These inventive mixes and playful variations will bring the spirit of Puerto Rico to any party. Whether it is the simple smooth Piña Highball-ada or the powerful and fun Piña Co-Lager, the Piña Colada and all its variants continue to prove a taste of paradise is always within reach.
By Zach Sapato
